The Proprietors Bar and Table at 9 India Street on Nantucket is always worth a visit to sample Chef Michael LaScola’s imaginative a playful cuisine. You can order a large plate and an appetizer sample a number of the smaller plates instead. Between us, we did both. The menu changes frequently, so you may not order what we did, but the food is surprisingly good.
Right at the top of the menu was a Cream Puff filled with chicken liver mousse and rhubarb ($14). We split one. Not only was it quite filling, it was probably the biggest hit of the night for us: smooth and flavorful.
One of us opted for the Green Salad with buttermilk dressing, quinoa, rye crumb and aged Gouda ($25), and an exemplary salad it was.
We also tried the Pretzel Parker Rolls with Kobe’s duck pastrami, and sour cherry mustard ($29). This looked great on the plate, but the duck pastrami was so thin we never got a good taste of its flavor. We imagined we were supposed to make little sandwiches of the pastrami and sour cherry mustard, and that worked very well together.
One of us tried the seared scallops with hot and sour vin, caramelized shiitake, endive and turnip ($49.50) and found it excellent.
The other offering was narrated to us in a really noisy environment so we may have the title wrong. It amounted to Gnocchi with rabbit stew and onions ($39), but there may have been other descriptors we missed. The gravy and gnocchi were delicious, but there were but a few shreds of rabbit to be found. However, the overall taste was outstanding.
For dessert, we split a single Banana Bread Sundae, served with chocolate and caramel sauce and cherries ($20). It was terrific, but so filling we couldn’t (sigh) finish it.
Our bill with two glasses of wine with tax but before tip was $220.95. While there were some misses, the cuisine was overall unforgettable.